Guides for agents

What Should a Final Expense Lead Cost? A Break-Even Guide

There's no single right price for a final expense lead. The right price is the one your own numbers can support. This guide shows the break-even formula, a worked example, and why the cheapest lead is often not the cheapest sale.

The break-even formula

Break-even cost per lead = average commission per sale × close rate.

If you pay more than that per lead, every sale loses money before your time and other costs. Most agents aim well below break-even, for example spending no more than a quarter or a third of the commission on getting the lead.

A worked example (hypothetical numbers)

Say your average first-year commission on a final expense policy is $800 and you close 1 in 10 leads (10%).

  • Break-even cost per lead: $800 × 10% = $80.
  • If you want lead costs to use no more than 30% of the commission: $80 × 30% = $24 per lead target.
  • At a 5% close rate, the same math gives $40 break-even and a $12 target. At 15%, $120 and $36.

Use your own commission and your own close rate for each lead source. They differ a lot between agents, states and carriers, and the example above is not a prediction.

Why cost per lead can mislead

A $10 shared lead that four other agents also call may close far less often than a $45 exclusive lead. Divide total spend by policies written for each source; that cost per sale is the number that matters. Also count only reachable leads: if 20% of a source's leads are fake or unreachable, its true cost per lead is higher than the invoice says.

What moves the numbers

  • State and season: ad costs vary by market and rise around holidays and elections.
  • The offer and the ad: clear, specific ads that show the right audience bring better requests.
  • The form: a qualifying question trades a little volume for better leads.
  • Follow-up: several attempts over several days reach far more people than one call.

Track it every week

Keep a simple sheet per lead source: spend, leads, reachable leads, appointments, policies, commission. After a month you'll know your real cost per sale and which sources earn their price.

See a real campaign and its numbers

More guides

Written by the Teeb Leads team (TEEBTRADING LLC, a marketing company, not an insurance agency). General information for licensed agents, not legal, tax or financial advice. Reviewed October 10, 2026.