Guides for agents

Exclusive vs. Shared Insurance Leads: What Agents Should Know

Short answer: a shared lead is sold to several agents, so you race other agents to the same person. An exclusive lead goes to one agent only. Exclusive leads cost more per lead, so the right choice depends on what each lead turns into, not the sticker price.

What a shared lead is

A shared lead is one consumer's request sold to more than one agent, often three to five or more. The vendor spreads its ad cost across several buyers, which is why shared leads are cheaper per lead. The trade-off is competition: the consumer may get calls from several agents within minutes, and many stop answering unknown numbers after the first one or two calls.

What an exclusive lead is

An exclusive lead is delivered to one agent and not resold, so no other agent is sold that lead. You are not racing other buyers of the same lead, and you can follow up over several days without another lead buyer closing the case first. (The person may still have asked other companies too.)

"Exclusive" means different things at different vendors. Some sell a lead to one agent but resell it later as an "aged" lead. Some run the ads in their own accounts and choose which agent gets which lead. The strongest version is a campaign that runs in an ad account set up only for you, so every lead it produces is yours by design.

Aged leads

Aged leads are older requests, often weeks or months old, sold at a steep discount. They can work for agents with a strong follow-up process, but expect much lower contact rates, and check that the original consent covers your calls and texts.

How to compare them fairly

Compare cost per sale, not cost per lead. A cheap lead that rarely picks up can cost more per sale than an expensive one that does. For any vendor, track for at least a few weeks:

  • Contact rate: the share of leads you actually reach.
  • Close rate: the share of leads that become policies.
  • Cost per sale: total spend divided by policies written.
  • Bad data: wrong numbers, fake names and duplicates. Ask whether the vendor replaces them.

Questions to ask any lead vendor

  1. How many agents receive each lead, and is it ever resold later?
  2. Where do the leads come from (which ads, which websites)?
  3. What exactly did the consumer agree to, and can I see the consent wording and the record for each lead?
  4. How fast are leads delivered after the form is sent?
  5. What happens with fake or duplicate leads?
  6. Do I own the ad account and the data if I stop?

For a fuller checklist, see how to choose a final expense lead vendor.

Where Teeb Leads fits

We build and run Facebook and Instagram lead campaigns in a dedicated Meta ad account for each agent. Meta bills ad spend to the agent's own card, every lead goes to that one agent in real time, and leads are never resold. Results vary by state, budget and season, and no number of leads or sales is guaranteed.

See a real campaign and its numbers

More guides

Written by the Teeb Leads team (TEEBTRADING LLC, a marketing company, not an insurance agency). General information for licensed agents, not legal, tax or financial advice. Reviewed October 10, 2026.